Conditions Precedent

Home ] Up ] AIG Europe v. Faraday Capital ] Bolton MBC v. Municipal Mutual (CofA) ] Cornhill v. Stamp Felt ] Eagle Star Insurance v. Cresswell and Others ] GAN v. Tai Ping ] George Hunt Cranes ] RSA Insurance v. Dornoch CofA ] Shinedean v. Alldown (CofA) ] Sirius v. Friends Provident ]

AIG Europe (Ireland) Ltd v Faraday Capital Ltd
English Commercial Court: Morison J: [2006] EWHC 2707 (Comm): 31 October 2006
REINSURANCE: DIRECTORS AND OFFICERS INSURANCE POLICY: NOTIFICATION OF LOSS CLAUSE/CLAIMS CO-OPERATION CLAUSE: CONDITION PRECEDENT: PROPER CONSTRUCTION OF CLAUSE


Shinedean Ltd v Alldown Demolition (London) Ltd and Others
English Court of Appeal: Sir Anthony Clarke MR, May and Gage LJJ: [2006] EWCA Civ 939: 20 June 2006
PUBLIC LIABILITY AND CONTRACTORS’ ALL RISKS INSURANCE POLICY: LIABILITY TO INDEMNIFY: CLAIMS CONTROL CLAUSE: CONDITION PRECEDENT: OBLIGATION TO PROVIDE "ALL NECESSARY INFORMATION AND ASSISTANCE": COMPLIANCE WITH CLAUSE WITHIN AN IMPLIED "REASONABLE TIME": RELEVANCE OF "PREJUDICE" TO INSURER AS A FACTOR IN DETERMINING "A REASONABLE TIME"

Shinedean Ltd v Alldown Demolition (London) Ltd (In Liquidation) and AXA Insurance UK Plc
English High Court, Technology & Construction Division: Judge Richard Havery: [2005] EWHC 2319 (TCC): 28 October 2005
INSURANCE: CLAIMS CONTROL CLAUSES: WHETHER CONDITIONS PRECEDENT TO INSURER’S LIABILITY: OBLIGATION TO PROVIDE DOCUMENTS: NO TIME LIMIT PRESCRIBED: WHETHER DOCUMENTS PROVIDED IN REASONABLE TIME: WHAT IS ‘REASONABLE’?: INTERPRETATION GENEROUS TO THE INSURED: WHETHER PREJUDICE TO INSURER A FACTOR IN REASONABLENESS

Bolton Metropolitan Borough Council v Municipal Mutual Insurance Ltd and Commercial Union Insurance Co Ltd
English Court of Appeal: Auld, Longmore and Hallett LJJ.: [2006] EWCA Civ 50: 6 February 2006
INSURANCE: LOCAL AUTHORITIES: PUBLIC LIABILITY INSURANCE: ACCIDENTAL BODILY INJURY OR ILLNESS OCCURRING DURING CURRENCY OF POLICY: MESOTHELIOMA: WHETHER CLAIM AROSE ON FIRST EXPOSURE TO ASBESTOS FIBRES OR LATER WHEN MALIGNANCY DEVELOPED OR SYMPTOMS OF DISEASE FIRST BECAME APPARENT: LATE NOTIFICATION OF CLAIM: CONDITION PRECEDENT: WHETHER WAIVED BY INSURER

Bolton Metropolitan Borough Council v Municipal Mutual Insurance Ltd and Commercial Union Assurance Co Ltd
English High Court (Manchester): Michael Kershaw QC: 28 May 2005
ASBESTOS: INHALATION OF FIBRES: DEVELOPMENT OF MESOTHELIOMA: PUBLIC LIABILITY INSURANCE: ACCIDENTAL BODILY INJURY OR ILLNESS OCCURRING DURING CURRENCY OF POLICY: WHEN DID ACCIDENT OCCUR: MEANING OF ‘ACCIDENT’: LATE NOTIFICATION OF CLAIM: CONDITION PRECEDENT: WHETHER LATE NOTIFICATION WAIVED: DOUBLE INSURANCE: BASIS OF CONTRIBUTION

Sirius International Insurance v Friends Provident Life & Pensions Ltd
English Court of Appeal: Waller and Mance LJJ., Sir William Aldous: [2005] EWCA Civ
60: 24 May 2005
PROFESSIONAL INDEMNITY INSURANCE: EXCESS LAYER: BREACH OF
NOTICE CLAUSE: WHETHER AN INNOMINATE TERM: WHETHER INSURER ENTITLED TO AVOID THE CLAIM: WHETHER PARTIAL REPUDIATION OF AN INSURANCE CONTRACT POSSIBLE: SERIOUS CONSEQUENCES: WHETHER DAMAGES AN ADEQUATE REMEDY

Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance Plc v Dornoch Limited & Others
English Court of Appeal: Brooke, Mance & Longmore LJJ: 10 March 2005
INSURANCE: LIABILITIES TO THIRD PARTIES: REINSURANCE: NOTIFICATION OF LOSS CLAUSE: CONDITION PRECEDENT TO REINSURERS’ LIABILITY: WHETHER "LOSS" MEANT "CLAIMED" OR "ALLEGED" LOSS: WHETHER "LOSS" MEANT "ACTUAL" LOSS: WHETHER LIABILITY FOR COSTS IS "ACTUAL LOSS": KNOWLEDGE OF LOSS

Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance Plc v Dornoch Ltd & Others
English Commercial Court: Aikens J.: [2004] EWHC 803 (Comm): 22 April 2004
 INSURANCE: REINSURANCE: CLAIMS CONTROL CLAUSE: 72-HOUR NOTICE CLAUSE: "KNOWLEDGE OF ANY LOSS": MEANING OF "LOSS": MEANING OF "KNOWLEDGE"

Eagle Star Insurance Co Ltd v J N Cresswell & Others
English Court of Appeal: Chadwick, Rix and Longmore LJJ.: 14 May 2004
INSURANCE: REINSURANCE: FOLLOW THE SETTLEMENTS CLAUSE: NOTICE: CLAIMS CONTROL CLAUSE: CLAIMS CO-OPERATION CLAUSE: OPTION: CONDITION PRECEDENT: INTERPRETATION OF CONFLICTING CLAUSES: TYPED CLAUSES: PRINTED CLAUSES

George Hunt Cranes Limited v Scottish Boiler and General Insurance Co Limited
English Court of Appeal: Potter LJ, Morland J: 3 December 2001
INSURANCE POLICY: CLAIM FOR DAMAGE TO HIRED EQUIPMENT: NOTIFICATION CLAUSE: WHETHER COMPLIANCE WITH NOTIFICATION CLAUSE A CONDITION PRECEDENT TO INSURERS’ LIABILITY

Cornhill Insurance Plc v. D E Stamp Felt Roofing Contractors Ltd.
English Court of Appeal: Pill and Longmore LJJ, Sir Denis Henry: March 2002
INSURANCE: PUBLIC LIABILITY INSURANCE POLICIES: FLAT ROOFING BUSINESS: FIRE:
POLICY CONDITIONS: BREACH OF CONDITIONS: REFUSAL TO INDEMNIFY: ARRANGING FOR PRECAUTIONS TO BE TAKEN: UNDERTAKING THAT PRECAUTIONS HAD BEEN TAKEN: ABSOLUTE OBLIGATIONS

GAN Insurance Company v.Tai Ping Insurance Company 
English Court of Appeal: Mance and Latham LJJ; Sir Christopher Staughton; July 2001: 2001 CLC 1133
REINSURANCE: CLAIMS CO-OPERATION CLAUSE (‘CCC’): CCC A CONDITION PRECEDENT: INTERPRETATION OF ‘AND’: BREACH OF CLAUSE OVERRIDES ‘FOLLOW SETTLEMENTS CLAUSE: REINSURERS MUST NOT WITHHOLD SETTLEMENT APPROVAL UNREASONABLY

Back to Top

 

These Case Notes have been prepared with care, but neither the Editor nor the International and other Contributors can guarantee that they are free from error, nor that they contain every pertinent point. Reliance should not therefore be placed upon them without independent verification. The Editor and the International and other Contributors disclaim all liability for any loss of whatsoever nature and howsoever arising as a result of others acting or refraining from acting in reliance on the contents of this website and the information to which it gives access. The Editor claims copyright in the content of the website.